36-year old Miguel Cotto is in the midst winding down a long and storied career. The Puerto Rican fighter achieved true Pay-Per-View star status during his peak, participated in some great fights, and put himself at the top of the boxing world for years. He’s a lock for the Boxing Hall of Fame, and he deserves to be. After his most recent bout, he said he was retiring after one last fight later this year. To give context on one of the biggest stars of his generation, I decided to go back through the last decade or so and follow his career trajectory to take a closer look at how strong his boxing resume really is.
Cotto had some great years in the mid-2000s, especially 2007. To his credit, he continued to fight in relevant fights for years, but looking back he really did have some smart matchmaking, and lost nearly every time he stepped up in class as he got older. That said, he’s among many boxing fans’ favorite fighters for good reason – he made an entertaining scrap. Note that for some fights I only have my scorecard to go on, and for others I have full notes, but it’s fun to look back at one of recent history’s most entertaining careers.
Let’s go down the Cotto rabbit hole, starting in 2006:
June 10, 2006: Miguel Cotto UD12 Paulie Malignaggi
STW Scorecard: Cotto 116-111 Malignaggi
Before Malignaggi became the good boxing announcer/terrible person that he is today, he was a light-punching but talented technical fighter who made himself a solid career despite not being able to punch his way through tissue paper. Malignaggi gave a good account of himself in this fight, broadcast on HBO, as a prime Cotto flashed that wicked left hook and power punching that battered Paulie around the ring, including a knockdown in R2. I gave Malignaggi 4 rounds in a spirited effort, but Cotto was just way too much for him here.
December 2, 2006: Miguel Cotto TKO6 Carlos Quintana
STW Scorecard: Cotto 48-45 Quintana
Few times has Cotto looked more dominant in his career than this fight against fellow Puerto Rican Quintana. After starting a little slow with the spirited Quintana winning 2 of the first 3 rounds on my card, HBO rightfully was salivating over how powerful Cotto looked, as he battered Quintana around the ring in R5, knocking him down twice as Quintana barely hung on to end the round. His corner through in the towel, and Cotto looked like a true force.
June 9, 2007: Miguel Cotto KO11 Zab Judah
STW Scorecard: Cotto 98-90 Judah
Am skipping Cotto’s stay-busy title defense against Oktay Urtel here. Cotto totally dominated the talented Judah here on HBO. After giving the first, feeling-out round to Judah, I had Cotto sweeping the fight (with a point deduction in the third), and really starting to beat him up later in the fight, including a knockdown in R9, before stopping him cold in R11. Very impressive Cotto performance here.
November 10, 2007: Miguel Cotto UD12 Shane Mosley
STW Scorecard: Cotto 116-112 Mosley
2007 may have been Cotto’s high point as a boxer – back-to-back wins over Judah and Mosley are certainly nothing to sneeze at. This was a really fun fight, Cotto’s first on PPV. Cotto started off looking the stronger man and taking Mosley’s shots well, but Mosley had a really nice rally in R9 and R10 to get back in the fight and get the crowd hyped. Cotto however, recovered well in the championship rounds and took both of them in my card to take the deserved victory. There were a few close rounds (2, 7, 9) but overall Cotto earned what may have been a career-best victory.
April 12, 2008: Miguel Cotto TKO5 Alfonso Gomez
STW Scorecard: Cotto 50-42 Gomez
In Cotto’s return to HBO after his huge win over Mosley, he fought the way overmatched Gomez and steamrolled him. He scored knockdowns in rounds 2,3 and 5 with his power and pure boxing skill before the referee mercifully stopped the fight between rounds. A stay-busy fight for sure – but one in which Cotto looked great.
July 26, 2008: Antonio Margarito TKO11 Miguel Cotto
STW Scorecard: Margarito 97-93 Cotto
Ah, the infamous Cotto-Margarito bout. At the peak of his career, Cotto runs into a Mexican buzzsaw in the hard-punching Margarito, who continually moved forward through all of Cotto’s shots like a zombie all night long, systematically breaking down the Puerto Rican and giving him a beating that Cotto perhaps never quite fully recovered from. This became controversial later on as Margarito got busted in his next fight with illegal hand wraps, but at the time, the relentless Margarito overcame Cotto’s skill advantage to just beat the everloving shit out of Cotto, doing real damage from R7 on. Cotto wound up taking a knee and throwing in the towel in the 11th, and he couldn’t be blamed for doing so. Rough night for Cotto, especially after such a strong run.
February 21, 2009: Miguel Cotto TKO5 Michael Jennings
STW Scorecard: Cotto 40-34 Jennings
After taking a few months to recover from his beating at the hands of Margarito, Cotto made his return in an easier fight against the untested Jennings. Jennings, in way over his head, mostly tried to avoid Cotto’s power from the get go. He tried to stay out of range as Cotto sporadically landed the left hand, patiently beating him down by R3. Cotto hurt Jennings badly in R4 starting with a left to the head and then put him down twice with nasty lefts to the body. Jennings barely survived the round. He managed to make it through most of the 5th but took a knee after a wicked body shot from Cotto. Ref waved it off, not seeing enough to let the fight go on.
June 13, 2009: Miguel Cotto SD12 Joshua Clottey
STW Scorecard: Cotto 114-113 Clottey
Now this was an interesting fight for Cotto as he took on a much-avoided, strong fighter in Ghana’s Clottey. R1 was nip and tuck close with Cotto maybe a little ahead when, just before the end of the round, Cotto scored a key knockdown on a jab. That, at least on my scorecard, would be the difference in the fight. HBO’s announcers had Clottey doing well early, but I have Cotto up 4-2 (+ 1 KD) after the first half of the fight on just pure activity. In R4 Cotto began bleeding badly, hard round to score but thought he finished strong. In R5 Cotto body slammed Clottey, who was leaning on him in a clinch, and Clottey looked a little hurt, taking some time to resume the fight. In R7 and R8, Clottey was absolutely kicking Cotto’s ass. Cotto rebounded a bit in R9 but I still had Clottey taking it. Going into the last three rounds, I had it even, meaning taking 2 of the final 3 would give either fighter the win. Cotto looked hurt and winded going into those rounds, but Clottey absolutely blew this fight by becoming too inactive down the stretch, especially in rounds 10 and 11. He had this fight and lost it more than Cotto won it. A decision either way would have been fair, but Cotto deserved the razor thin decision in my mind. Clottey would later embarrass himself and effectively end his career with a total non-effort on PPV against Manny Pacquiao, but this was a huge missed opportunity for him.
November 14, 2009: Manny Pacquiao TKO12 Miguel Cotto
STW Scorecard: Pacquiao 108-99 Cotto
Gotta give Cotto credit – he didn’t waste too much time challenging a top level fighter a little more than a year removed from his huge beatdown against Margarito. This was Pacquiao at the height of his powers, and you forget how damn impressive he was during this time. This turned into a blowout on the scorecards, but it was a massively entertaining fight that was closer than the cards made it out to be, as Cotto had a couple rounds that were going his way that he lost at the end due to a knockdown (3 point swings).
R1 Manny started kind of slow, with R2 a close one but Manny taking it with a stronger finish. Pac got a KD to win R3 10-8 even though Cotto clearly won the rest of the round. R4 was incredible – it was a GREAT round for Cotto throughout and then Pac knocks him down (and hurts him) with 20 seconds left – wow. Cotto came back to edge R5 but Pac just started crushing him in R6, after which Cotto just started losing rounds, his face swelling up and getting on his bike just trying to survive. The second half of the fight was a systematic beatdown, and the ref showed mercy stopping it in the 12th. More of a reflection on just how good Pac was rather than a referendum on Cotto. Why Pac was a superstar, and Cotto was a star.
June 5, 2010: Miguel Cotto TKO9 Yuri Foreman
STW Scorecard: Cotto 79-73 Foreman
This was a weird fight – Cotto found a soft touch with a belt to come back against. Foreman really was never on the level of Cotto, and it showed right away as Cotto just outjabbed and outfought him early at Yankee Stadium on HBO. Foreman had a solid R4, landing with his right hand, but he slipped towards the end of the round and that might have aggravated a leg injury (he came into the fight with a brace on his knee). Cotto returned to outboxing the limited Foreman and in R7 Foreman completely blew his knee out, falling down twice and limping around the ring but showing a lot of heart to continue to trade despite the fact that he could barely move. In R8 a towel threw in, looked like Foreman’s corner was stopping it, but in a totally bizarre scene the ref didn’t want the fight stopped so he kicked everyone out of the ring and restarted. Did Foreman no favors though, as in R9 he took a nasty body shot from Cotto that dropped him and the ref finally stopped it. Just a weird fight.
March 12, 2011: Miguel Cotto TKO12 Ricardo Mayorga
STW Scorecard: Cotto 108-101 Mayorga
This is kind of the stage of his career where Cotto sort of got deliberate with his matchmaking. He fought an over-the-hill Mayorga in this fight on Showtime PPV and going in nobody gave the brash, trash talking Nicaraguan much of a chance. Cotto was the much better fighter technically, but R2 Mayorga managed to land some big shots. He’s fun to watch – in R3 he gets crazy, runs into the corner and yells at Cotto to come at him, but he still loses the round. That turns out to be a theme – Mayorga continues to talk and pose but lose rounds. In R7 he managed to land some good shots that seemed to affect Cotto but otherwise he didn’t have much success. Cotto hurt him pretty badly in R12 and Mayorga quit right there and then himself.
December 3, 2011: Miguel Cotto TKO9 Antonio Margarito
STW Scorecard: Cotto 89-82 Margarito
Cotto’s revenge fight on HBO PPV. Margarito, who since his big win three years prior was in a terrible downward spiral, taking an ass beating from Mosley and suffering through a suspension after the hand wrap scandal, was coming off just a total sustained beating against Pacquiao in which Pac broke his orbital bone and likely injured his eye beyond repair. The eye was a major storyline prefight (the commission even had an eye specialist ringside) and turned out to be a major part of the fight itself.
Cotto started the fight moving and boxing as Margarito did his usual come-forward zombie routine. R3 was really fun as Cotto stands and trades – Margarito already bleeding badly from that right eye. Cotto is the more skilled of the two and clearly landing the cleaner punches but Margarito just keeps coming forward. Cotto doing some major damage in R6 as Margarito’s eye is really compromised and he can’t seem to see out of it. After a couple of rounds of looking closely at the eye, the doctor stops the fight after R9. Even though it was a compromised Margs, must have felt good for Cotto to get his revenge.
May 6, 2012: Floyd Mayweather UD12 Miguel Cotto
STW Scorecard: Mayweather 116-112 Cotto
Cotto gets his big money fight against Mayweather on HBO PPV (Mayweather’s last HBO fight) and actually makes a good account of himself. Floyd starts off masterfully as usually – Cotto can’t land a clean shot at all and Floyd is peppering him with some nice shots. After dropping the first four rounds, Cotto found some success in R5 by muscling Floyd into the ropes – fun round. This is a relatively close fight – it’s tactical and not a barn burner but fought at a really high level. For a Floyd fight, especially at this stage in his career, it’s pretty entertaining. Cotto had a nice middle of the fight – I had him winning rounds 5,6,8 and 9 – but Mayweather pulled away at the end and even looked like he hurt Cotto in the final round. Nice performance from Floyd, but Cotto gave a good account of himself as well.
December 1, 2012: Austin Trout UD12 Miguel Cotto
STW Scorecard: Trout 116-112 Cotto
2012 was a tough year for Cotto as he took his second consecutive loss of the year when he challenged Austin Trout for a junior middleweight belt coming off his loss to Floyd. The first thing you notice as the fight starts is that Trout is way, way bigger than Cotto. Tough style matchup for the shorter man. Trout is effective using his length early to keep Cotto at the end of his jab in the first two rounds, even stunning Cotto a bit in R1. In R3 Cotto managed to get Trout to the ropes and though Trout countered nicely at times it was a tough one to score – I gave it to Miguel. Cotto got to him in R4, getting in some nice hooks at close range. Cotto finds a nice rhythm here in the early rounds – I have him up 4-2 after six rounds.
In R7, Trout turns the tide and never looks back. He pops his jab out and starts controlling the action, really picking him apart (though not really hurting him). He stuns Cotto a bit at the end of R10 and really dominates R11. The 12th was a fun round as the crowd started getting loud and into it with both guys sensing urgency and swinging, and Trout maybe getting the better of it a bit.
I had Trout sweeping the second half of the fight as Cotto just got outboxed and couldn’t seem to get anything going. Decent scrap though. The official scorecards were a little wide, but Cotto storms off in a huff like a huge sore loser. Really bad look for Miguel post fight – very ungraceful loss for him here. A low point in his illustrious career for sure.
October 5, 2013: Miguel Cotto TKO3 Delvin Rodriguez
STW Scorecard: Cotto 20-18 Rodriguez
After back-to-back losses to Trout and Mayweather, Cotto took nearly a full year off, coming back a weight class higher to take on the journeyman Rodriguez and with Freddie Roach in his corner. They tried to sell this as a new, more offensive-minded fighter, but what it really was was a good veteran fighter dominating a limited opponent, stopping him in R3. This is another transition in the career of Cotto, as he competed at a higher weight class and began cherrypicking opponents.
June 7, 2014: Miguel Cotto TKO10 Sergio Martinez
STW Scorecard: Cotto 90-77 Martinez
This fight- which I went to live – made me sad. Martinez was at this time the lineal middleweight champion defending his title, approaching 40 years old and had given the sport a handful of years where his star shined bright in good, entertaining fights, making himself into a star (though not a superstar) and giving himself a HOF-worthy run at middleweight. He had notably struggled in his last couple of fights with injuries, and came into the fight having had two knee surgeries and been inactive for about a year. Cotto was the smaller man stepping up in weight, and the two met at Madison Square Garden to duke it out.
Turns out Martinez was cashing out, in what would be his final fight. He just had nothing for Cotto, who looked great, though it was a little hard to judge as Sergio was badly, badly compromised from the jump. His leg was unstable and he could barely move. Cotto came out quick and aggressive and Martinez just couldn’t handle it, getting knocked down three times in the first round alone. Cotto continued his assault as the rounds wore on, and Martinez showed heart to stay in it, but Cotto just dominated him every second. Cotto scored another knockdown in R9 when he caught Sergio with a jab coming in. After the round, his corner tells him his knees aren’t working and they have to stop it, ending the champion’s career. Great performance from Cotto, but with, unfortunately, an asterisk.
June 6, 2015: Miguel Cotto TKO4 Daniel Geale
STW Scorecard: Cotto 30-27 Geale
A less than impressive win for Cotto. After winning the lineal middleweight title from a one-legged Martinez, Cotto weight drained Australia’s Geale to the point that he posed nearly no danger and looked like a zombie on fight night. Cotto never really was challenged in this one as his hook found a home on the drained Geale and he stopped him easily in 4 rounds. This was a cynical one from Cotto.
November 21, 2015: Canelo Alvarez UD12 Miguel Cotto
STW Scorecard: Alvarez 117-111 Cotto
This was an exciting one on paper, a fight on HBO PPV between the veteran Cotto and the young star Alvarez. Ultimately it wound up being a nice scalp for Alvarez, who boxed well in a tactical affair as it really seemed like their size difference (Canelo having a 10+ lb weight advantage on fight night) made a huge impact as none of Cotto’s shots seemed to hurt Canelo at all. Thought it was a pretty clear Canelo win, with Cotto taking only rounds 1,4 and 9, but it wasn’t boring. This gave Canelo the lineal middleweight title. After this fight, Cotto took nearly two years off.
August 26, 2017: Miguel Cotto UD12 Yoshihiro Kamegai
STW Scorecard: Cotto 119-109 Kamegai
After nearly two full years out of the ring, Cotto returned this past August in a card that, unfortunately for Cotto, had to compete with the Mayweather-McGregor spectacle, meaning that the only people who watched this fight was the fighter’s respective families and the HBO broadcasting team assigned to cover this. Cotto has called this his second-to-last fight and it was a good test to see how much Cotto had left.
Turns out, he has enough at this level to look good. Cotto dominated this fight – I gave Kamegai R1 on aggression and then scored every other round for Cotto. The Puerto Rican landed at will all night, bloodying up Kamegai while moving backward as the Japanese man came forward like a horror movie zombie. Cotto landed so hard that Kamegai’s chin would often end up over his shoulder looking in the other direction, but Kamegai just keeps coming forward and taking it. I started wondering if they should stop it as early as R7, but Kamegai survives the rest of the fight, which was way too repetitive and one sided to be that interesting. Cotto remains in a different class from the C-level competition, and looks like he still has something to offer if he does indeed retire after his next fight.